Similar to how my scrawling schoolboy script has deteriorated across a quarter-century of digital document creation, my natural urge to halt and record progress in a game waned. I blame the emergence of automatic saving, save points, console quick-resume features, and games with such high stakes that I instinctively save obsessively in case things blow up. But I’m not perfect. I get lazy. And this week, I was taught an important lesson deep into a session of the newly ported Pokémon FireRed on the Switch: you still gotta manually hit save.
Many years had gone by since I engaged with a classic Pokémon title — never experiencing the GBA era, the Johto region games were likely the most recent traditional Pokémon journey I completed. Therefore, I was excited to pony up $19.99 for the nostalgic return to the Kanto region, and a quest to catch those classic 151 Pokémon. I immediately snapped back to a simpler time. Over a few successive evenings, I snagged Caterpie and Weedle, picked up an early Pikachu, defeated the first Gym Leader on my first turn, took a chance on purchasing the Magikarp from a shady character, and journeyed through Mt. Moon completely unconcerned.
The fatal flaw: I failed to save even once! The idea simply didn't occur to me.
Jigglypuff will never find love with my Mankey.
Disaster struck during a session where I didn’t play FireRed… and as my daughter picked up the Switch for a quick half-hour of the newer Pokémon title instead, shutting down my session in the process. As any Switch user understands (as I should have known…) launching a different title on the system forces the closure of your current game. Your progress is only safe if the game autosaved or you saved manually before switching. Oops.
The Progression of Game Saves: From Manual to Automatic
One could view automatic saving, now so effortless its operation is largely unconscious, as a true “cutting-edge” breakthrough. While PC text adventure Zork had one of the earliest save systems in gaming, 1986’s The Legend of Zelda is often credited as a pivotal point for alleviating the sensation of being totally ruined after a game over because of persistent memory saves on NES cartridges. Of course, the responsibility remained to save. (And once you erred), it was a mistake made only once. During the nineties, save cards for systems like PlayStation normalized the save process yet still fragile; failing to save (or having a card corrupt) could wipe hours of progress. Titles such as Resident Evil took it further by transforming saving into a scarce commodity.
Contemporary background saving, which suppressed my instinct to save my retro gaming session so completely, gained prominence in the early 2000s. Halo: Combat Evolved had its automatic checkpoints as the Call of Duty series refined the system to ease frustration and reduce tedious replay. As experiences became more vast — and focused on exploration — programmers mastered the technique of persistent, invisible saving and, eventually, the holy grail of picking up exactly where you left off.
A Franchise's Adaptation: From Manual Ritual to Modern Convenience
Curiously, this iconic franchise serves as a perfect mirror of that technological evolution. For a long time, preserving your Pokédex progress was manual: fans were taught to select the Save option prior to shutting off their device. Starting with Pokémon Sword and Shield on Switch, the games added an autosave feature (at first as a toggleable option), marking a major design shift within one of the industry's most most tradition-bound franchises.
I own up to my blunder: Years of playing Breath of the Wild and contemporary Nintendo titles utterly weakened my instinct to save. I still know better in some cases — I refuse to chance exiting prematurely in a challenging indie title despite being aware it has a robust save system — but be it because the lengthy gap since I last invested classic gaming mechanics, or I’ve just been spoiled, the thought never entered my mind to preserve my progress when I stopped playing. Seven-year-old me would not have made such a mistake so catastrophically.
The Consequences: Starting From Scratch
I have not opened FireRed after my data loss incident. Upon rebooting the game to see I had only Squirtle on my roster, a wave of exhaustion hit me. The verdict: Burned.
I might give it another shot… or I could just continue playing the hundreds of new games available now that operate under the assumption I can’t remember to save. Still, my affection for classic games persists. During times I can distract my child to take a break from the modern, auto-saving Pokémon game, we have been cooperatively playing a collection of classic Bomberman games. Those classic titles skipped saving altogether opting instead for old-school passwords. Therefore, if I make a fatal mistake, it’s not a total loss. For now, that’s comfort.